Our Story



News & Updates

Legacy Coffee in Montclair is now featuring our SuperDeluxe Cookies, Fudge Brownies, and Peanut Butter Cookies in their pastry case. You can also find our seasonal specials, including Apple Pie Bars and Pumpkin Pie Bars. All pair well with their fantastic coffee.

Just two more dates left in the [official] Farmers Market season in Westfield! We’ll see you on October 19th and October 26th from 8:30 to 1:30 on the North side of the train station. Sign up for our newsletter - we hope to be back for a special pre-Thanksgiving market and will send you details!

Our Thanksgiving Menu is now live! Savory biscuits for your dinner table, PIE PIE and MORE PIE, plus crowd favorites like Pumpkin Chocolate Bread & Mom’s Almond Cookies. PLUS we’re offering home delivery to residents in the Westfield area. See order instructions for more information.




At A Butter Life, we believe in love at first bite—rich, savory goodness that stops you in your tracks. That sweet-meets-salty combo that sweeps you off your feet, taste that transcends, and flavor that fuels the need for just one more little nibble. Food-snobs at heart, we’re taking our love of high-end treats and catering to our inner child, for a combination of simple-yet-sophisticated that’s meant to bring back old memories and create new ones.

Where to find us!

Legacy Coffee, Montclair NJ

Saturdays through October 26th: Westfield NJ Farmers Market

  • Open 8:30am to 1:30pm at the North Avenue Train Station. Free parking available in South Lot 3.