Menu

Cakes


Current Specials

Thanksgiving

Cakes

 
A party without cake is just a meeting.
— Julia Child
 
 

A Butter Life cakes offer a unique combination of flavors & textures designed to make your mouth water and your heart sing! From our flavorful cake layers to fillings and buttercream frosting, every morsel of our cakes is made to order from scratch.

Curious about our work? Check out our Gallery for pics, and we welcome requests for references.

 
 
 

Signature Cakes

 

 
 

NEW! Lemon Meringue

Yellow Cake, Lemon Curd Filling, Lemon Buttercream, covered in a toasted whipped meringue. Also available gluten-free.

NEW! Black & White

Chocolate Cake, Ganache Filling, Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Crunchies

Caramel Cookie Crumble

Yellow Cake, Caramel Buttercream, Crumbled Brown Sugar Cookies, Caramel Drip

Chai Cake

Yellow Cake, Chai Tea Buttercream, Caramel Drizzle, Crumbled Grahams

The Turtle

Choice of Vanilla or Chocolate Cake, filled with spirals of Caramel Buttercream & Chocolate Ganache with caramel drizzle and toasted pecans, and finished with Caramel Buttercream

 
 
 

Custom Cakes


 
 

We bake to bring your sweet dreams to life! Contact us about crafting your custom cake.

Whether it’s recreating a favorite cake from your childhood or helping you celebrate family & friends, we bake to bring your sweet dreams to life! Contact us about crafting your custom cake.

 
 
 

Cake Sizes & Pricing


 

6” Round / 10 to 12 Servings, starting at $48

8” Round / 16 to 18 Servings, starting at $70

9” Round / 20 to 22 Servings, starting at $88

10” Round / 32 Servings, starting at $125

 
 

Our calendar fills quickly, so please contact us to check availability. Pick-up is available in Glen Ridge and Kenilworth. Door-to-door delivery is available in Montclair, Glen Ridge, Bloomfield, Westfield, Cranford, Kenilworth, Scotch Plains, Mountainside, and Fanwood for an additional fee.

 
 

VenMo, GooglePay, & Zelle Payments accepted & due at order.